I tested all three platforms extensively. Here's the honest breakdown of ColdSend vs Smartlead vs Instantly.
Spoiler: Each platform serves different needs. Here's how to choose.
Platform Overview Comparison
ColdSend
- Focus: No-warmup infrastructure (learn how it works)
- Best for: Teams who need immediate deployment
- Unique advantage: Start sending day one
Smartlead
- Focus: Lead generation + email sending
- Best for: Teams wanting all-in-one solution
- Unique advantage: Built-in lead finding
Instantly
- Focus: Advanced automation features
- Best for: Complex, multi-step campaigns
- Unique advantage: Sophisticated sequences
Pricing Breakdown
ColdSend: $50/month
- 100 inboxes included
- 10,000 emails/month
- No setup fees
- Hidden costs: None (see why agencies love this)
Smartlead: $94/month
- 15 inboxes included
- 8,000 emails/month
- Additional inboxes: $7/month each
- Hidden costs: Extra inbox fees add up fast
Instantly: $297/month
- 50 inboxes included
- 5,000 emails/month
- Additional features cost extra
- Hidden costs: Per-feature pricing
Winner: ColdSend for transparent pricing (calculate your savings)
Feature Comparison
| Feature | ColdSend | Smartlead | Instantly |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup Time | Same day | 2-3 weeks | 2-3 weeks |
| Warmup Required | No | Yes | Yes |
| Inbox Limit | 100+ | 15 base | 50 base |
| API Access | Full | Limited | Limited |
| Lead Generation | No | Yes | No |
| Automation | Basic | Advanced | Advanced |
| Deliverability | 90%+ | 80-85% | 75-80% |
Winner: Depends on your needs (learn why infrastructure matters more than features)
Which Platform to Choose
Choose ColdSend if:
- You need to start immediately (see how fast)
- You want transparent pricing
- You value deliverability above all else
- You need lots of inboxes
Choose Smartlead if:
- You want built-in lead generation
- You can wait 2-3 weeks for warmup
- You're okay with additional inbox fees
- You need moderate automation
Choose Instantly if:
- You need complex automation sequences
- You have a large budget
- You can manage the learning curve
- You want advanced features
The Bottom Line
For immediate deployment: ColdSend wins
For all-in-one solution: Smartlead wins
For advanced automation: Instantly wins
Most sales teams choose ColdSend because time to market matters more than fancy features. Learn why.
Ready to compare platforms yourself? Try ColdSend and see the difference immediate deployment makes.
Related Articles:
LinkedIn
Twitter